Hello and welcome to the first posting of a songwriting blog. Songwriting is probably a little too specific- what I want to do with this blog is to talk about some of my feelings and theories as to what makes a great pop record. Perhaps I'll branch of into other idioms now and then, but pop itself, by my definition, is pretty broad, meaning anything that's NOT jazz or classical or world music. Within that framework, I'll consider Leadybelly and Mississipi John Hurt pop music just as I would The Ronnettes, or, say, Ace Of Base.
Normally when someone does this sort of thing it's because they've proven successful in the field they're getting pedantic about. That doesn't exactly describe me, uh, so much or anything, but I'm doing this anyway. Why? Because about 80% of my daily thoughts, waking and dreaming, are spent on the subject. Because it amuses me to think about and talk about and I'm assuming it will amuse me to write about as well. Because there's no other really good reason to do a craft other than the fact that it amuses you, and makes you at least useful to yourself. I'd argue that there's no other purpose in life, actually.
hi ho.
I am of the firm opinion that songwriting and record-making are crafts first and foremost, much as one would call carpentry, masonry, baking, cooking, or cabinet-making. My father was a cabinet-maker- I'd also call him an artist- but he certainly wasn't an artist on purpose. He didn't sit around thinking "I am an artist- I will await messages from the mystical doohickey yonder who will tell me how many dovetails to add to this chest-of-drawers". He went to the shop in the big red barn next to our house and he did his craft every day. To him, it was a skill-one to be improved through hard work, careful thought, practice, and persistence. There was nothing mystical about it. Yet he was an artist at it, and his pieces- often restorations or imitations of 17th & 18th century Shaker & Victorian furniture, had all the tell-tale signs of genius in them- and that's how people in his business regarded him.
Anyway, the point is, talent isn't something the person engaged in their craft should think about at all. Talent is something people accuse other people of having- but the reality is that good artists in any medium, more often than not, are skilled technicians of one sort or another, constantly pounding away at their figurative slab of marble, trying to get it perfect. That, to me, is what art is, but I prefer to call it craft, because people have so many unbelievably vain and silly ideas about ART.
So, then, I'm doing this mostly for my own amusement, and partially because I think that maybe talking about this stuff "out loud" will actually help me to improve my own craft. I'm also hoping to start a lot of conversations with whoever reads this thing. Little fascinates me more than how other people approach the same craft. So even if you're not a musician but have many strong ideas about what makes a pop song good, please do comment. I need brains.
Normally when someone does this sort of thing it's because they've proven successful in the field they're getting pedantic about. That doesn't exactly describe me, uh, so much or anything, but I'm doing this anyway. Why? Because about 80% of my daily thoughts, waking and dreaming, are spent on the subject. Because it amuses me to think about and talk about and I'm assuming it will amuse me to write about as well. Because there's no other really good reason to do a craft other than the fact that it amuses you, and makes you at least useful to yourself. I'd argue that there's no other purpose in life, actually.
hi ho.
I am of the firm opinion that songwriting and record-making are crafts first and foremost, much as one would call carpentry, masonry, baking, cooking, or cabinet-making. My father was a cabinet-maker- I'd also call him an artist- but he certainly wasn't an artist on purpose. He didn't sit around thinking "I am an artist- I will await messages from the mystical doohickey yonder who will tell me how many dovetails to add to this chest-of-drawers". He went to the shop in the big red barn next to our house and he did his craft every day. To him, it was a skill-one to be improved through hard work, careful thought, practice, and persistence. There was nothing mystical about it. Yet he was an artist at it, and his pieces- often restorations or imitations of 17th & 18th century Shaker & Victorian furniture, had all the tell-tale signs of genius in them- and that's how people in his business regarded him.
Anyway, the point is, talent isn't something the person engaged in their craft should think about at all. Talent is something people accuse other people of having- but the reality is that good artists in any medium, more often than not, are skilled technicians of one sort or another, constantly pounding away at their figurative slab of marble, trying to get it perfect. That, to me, is what art is, but I prefer to call it craft, because people have so many unbelievably vain and silly ideas about ART.
So, then, I'm doing this mostly for my own amusement, and partially because I think that maybe talking about this stuff "out loud" will actually help me to improve my own craft. I'm also hoping to start a lot of conversations with whoever reads this thing. Little fascinates me more than how other people approach the same craft. So even if you're not a musician but have many strong ideas about what makes a pop song good, please do comment. I need brains.

1 Comments:
I'm looking forward to this.
Post a Comment
<< Home