Monday, October 30, 2006

Making Up Songs

When I was a kid I used to make up songs all the time. This is common behavior for children but some of us get a little more into it than others. I remember a nonsensical (sarcastic !!!s) song called "Mommy Gaurami" that I used to sing while waiting to be picked up from school at the end of the day (this school didn't have a bus system- later in public high school, the bus ride home proved to be one of the best times to make up songs). Anyway, the song was based on "Is You Is Or Is You Ain't My Baby", at least the chords and the horn arrangement that ran through my head- although my melody was a little more....arabic? Anyway, I thought of this song years later as an adult and it occured to me that that horn line from it that I thought was so good was actually just ripped-off from "Is You Is?". But that was cool. I was a kid and I was using my imagination. That's never a bad thing.

A lot of songs, probably a lot of the best ones I'll ever make up, have been lost by virtue of not recording them in some fashion when they came into my head. When I was a drivin' man, it was kind of impossible- I'd have to wait till I got home to the four-track if something occurred to me, which meant I'd have to do nothing but sing the song until I was safely in front of a four track. An outside bit of music could easily derail the whole thing. Yet I let some songs go. I still have the vaguest memory of song I had in my head while driving down Pleasant St. in Amherst, MA., age 23. I wish I could actually remember it, but it's more like one of those abstract visuals that songs can become in my head- I can't remember anything about it other than its abstract visual is somewhat similiar to "Stephanie Says". It drives me nuts to this day as I'm quite sure it was great.

Nowadays, when something occurs to me, I call my cell phone and leave myself a message in which I hum the vocal melody, and bass riffs or drum things that are present, and mention the chord structure and approximate tempo. This is one of the only good things about cell phones for me. I thought of one song for the new album at 2:00 in the morning one winter night while walking from the subway- there's no way that one wouldn't have been swallowed by sleep. Luckiy I recorded a sketch of it.

Anyway, the thing I'm getting to is how different people conceptualize music. It does seem to be different from person to person. Personally, I think of music in three ways- one way is aural- that is usually regarding notes themselves. The second is color-coded- individual notes tend to imply colors. For example, C & E seem to be to be a blue and a darker blue. F is orange. A is red. The others are hazier but I won't go on.

The third way is the abstract visual way I mentioned before. This is even more pretentious-sounding than the color thing, so bear with me. Basically, a song or other piece of music will be represented by a visual in my head. Very often, especially for short-ish pop songs, this visual looks something like those line-perspective drawings you'd find in a book called "how to draw" or something. There's usually a front piece- somewhat like a giant, 3-dimensional letter in the alphabet, and there are lines coming from it going into a horizon. I don't think I could draw it. But it's there.

An orchestral, longer piece of music often looks like a dark, large pool of water. Sometimes it appears like a line drawing. Fast-paced bop or eary-60s modern jazz is weirdly more two-dimensional than either of them. I theorize that this is because the focus on a small number of instruments performing- i.e., lacking either the large variety of instruments of an orchestra or the production aspects of pop music, creates a much more simplistic image, despite the fact that the musical "sophistication" contained in such music tends to dwarf that of most pop or classic music- at least jazz of that period.

Anyway, I don't want to go on about jazz- but I will say this- I've heard from jazz snobs in the past (you only meet these people, generally, if you are or have been or hang out with jazz musicians, thank God) that their complaint with pop music is its lack of sophistication. I have to disagree. In terms of music theory, of course, this is correct. Most pop music is strictly diatonic or sparsely modal- the harmonic content does not stray far from the home key, in other words. It also tends to be short. Nonetheless, something that pop music, especially GREAT pop music, has in spades over classical or jazz is PRODUCTION. More than that, performances are informed by aesthetic concerns very often non existent in jazz and unheard of in classical.

That's why, for me, pop represents the pinnacle of achievement in Western music. There are no major aspects of jazz and classical that pop does not contain itself- the music is both partially pre-composed AND partially improvised. But jazz and classical lack the dimension of mechanical/analog/digital manipulation. They also lack the pretense of rock posturing- key to many of pop's greatest performances. For these reasons, pop offers more potential dimensions, more chances to be lost in an invented universe- more fantasy, to cut it short. Sound engineers who work in jazz do not often experiment in the studio. The focus is on respresenting the instruments realistically. Back when sound technology was in its relative infancy, this meant that jazz records sounded great. Now it means they sound sterile. Actually, this may lead to my talking about some recent production trends in pop and rock that make me unhappy. Maybe next time, though.

4 Comments:

Blogger Bruce Dazzling said...

Has anyone ever told you that you're the Neville Chamberlain of the song-writing blog community?

You ARE different in your approach to writing music. I think it's safe to say that very few people hear entire songs, fully arranged, in their heads before even picking up an instrument. Your ability to hear chords, drums, rhythms, words, and melody simultaneously, and then to simply record what you hear in your head is astonishingly rare, I would say. I certainly don't (can't ) work that way. I never get more than one aspect of a song in my head before picking up an instrument, and it's usually just a melody that I struggle to find on the guitar. Once I've got the first idea, I record it, so that I can put it out of my head and concentrate on the next idea, which is usually chords that work with the melody. I work this way because I have to. At no point have I ever been able to hear a melody in my head and also figure out the backing chords without playing it on an instrument (not to even mention drums, bass, etc). Your brain works in a magical way, asshole, and I hate you for it.

4:13 PM  
Blogger Arcandy said...

I don't know if you're right, but certainly everyone's brain works differently. thanks for the compliment?

10:25 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

From the new Encyclopedia Brown, Wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genius

"The classical skill of the musical genius is the capability of holding many different melodies in one's head at once and knowing how they interact together. It is said that the great classical composers (Bach, Mozart, etc) could hold five, six or even seven different melodies in their minds at once. They could write complicated music with many different parts all at once without having to hear it played. In comparison, the average person can only hold one melody in memory."

2:56 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

O, Athena, sprung fully-formed from the head of Zeus...what a headache she gave...

This same thing happens to me with stories. Used to happen with music too, to a lesser degree. I remember doing the bit with the answering machine more than once. Even though I once had a band in college and really did love to write songs, I never did qualify as a 'musician.' There did seem to be a prerequisite for the title, something involving actually knowing the names of the notes...? Honestly, I was too easily distracted in my interests to be able to give up my somewhat dilettante-ish love of doing 6 different things at once to properly remember which chords were which. I was always more like, "hmm, that sounds pretty." I had a better shot at making a living visually (I'm a graphic designer) than with music, so graphic design eventually won out by default. I do still get tunes in my head that are lost to the cosmos...

Anyway, I find this and the previous post fascinating for a number of reasons, a primary one being the notion that there is a primal language, with a fairly limited basic vocabulary that yields extraordinarily nuanced and complex results. You seem to be gifted/suffering from a type of synesthesia, judging by how your 'musical vision' manifests itself. I have had very much the same experience with the sound/color association, but wound up coming down in the visual camp.

In design, I'm working with a primary set of colors and shapes, that signify, combine and dilute much like music. There are fairly well-established signifiers that come up again and again, and the longer I do this gig, the more aware I am of the pre-existing language. There are major and minor keys in the visual as well as the musical. There is an understood lexicon, though whether it exists because of a primal reaction to certain visual stimuli or as a result of societal accretion is something of a chicken-and-egg question.

The capacity to pluck whole ideas from the ether is a fairly well-documented phenomenon, stretching historically across the varying creative disciplines: music-->mathematics-->physics-->design-->visual art. I include the sciences in the creative disciplines because I really believe that they are closely related manifestations of the imagination at work. DaVinci, Newton, Turing, Tesla, Edison, are perfect examples. I think Edison even said that bit about plucking ideas out of thin air...though his may have been an intellectually larcenous sort of plucking.

Anyway, the attempt to create something 'original' is far less of a goal for me than the attainment of a perfect execution, which is something I am in constant pursuit of. I take my role as crafts(wo)man a lot more seriously the more I come to appreciate the tradition and history of what I'm engaged in. As an art, eh, I don't know. I like the idea of the accidental art object. Works that come to be appreciated as art long after their creation rather than the notion of setting out to 'create art.' I think the willingness to experiment is probably a higher form of creative thought than the idea of hewing closely to a purist notion of what one thinks constitutes art in the first place.

Truth be told, I've been finding the whole 'artist' thing a little irritating of late, since the bit of creativity and imagination I am lucky enough to possess could probably do a lot more good out in the world attempting to solve problems than merely commenting on the sad state of affairs. There's a great article about a guy doing just that in last sunday's NYT. Went from painting to community planning. The guy's brilliant and he's done a lot of good. I felt pretty inspired and started thinking about the potential power of design.

I digress. I'm good at that.

We can't help but borrow. We borrow from the moment we're born and it's how we learn. Yet each of us manages to become an amazingly different person. We go about gathering traits and habits, keeping and discarding attributes, formulating personalities that have no way of existing independently from the environments that created them by virtue of the choices we may be genetically pre-programmed to make. We are very much an amalgam of nature and nurture, each being inextricable from the other. What we have the ability to create while still in the process of creating ourselves blows my mind.

8:01 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home