Wednesday, September 13, 2006

Stealing Is Good

About 6 years ago (ach!) I was in a band back in Massachusetts that was doing pretty well in our area. The band itself was a really loud pop band that sounded more like the Jesus & Mary Chain, David Bowie, and The Velvet Underground than anything else, with flourishes of Mission Of Burma and the like later. Anyway, your typical arty pop collage. At some point (I think after we opened up for -tah-dah!- Superdrag (whose "Sucked Out" marks, for me, one of the better moments in 90s mainstream radio) we got a blurb and a picture in the regional Village Voice- style liberal arts & news paper, and all hell broke loose in the letters section!!!

The guy who wrote the article was a really nice guy named Kebrew who lives in New York now. He said, in a nutshell, that we were really good, although we ripped various other bands off- but that we were still really good despite that- I believe pulling out the old "great artists steal" bit. Anyway, I recall being mildy annoyed that he felt compelled to mention it (even though it was true), but we were happy with the praise otherwise. The next week, there was an angry letter from a "local singer-songwriter"- (i.e., some po-mo folkie hack who does white melisma over sus4 and sus2 chords and calls it music) shaming said writer for praising a band who rips other songwriters off. They a whole diatribe about the importance of originality in music and your personal voice and a lot of other misguided hooey that could only come from someone who considers themselves an artist instead of a craftsman.

That's all fine for them, but let me say something- originality, just like sincerity, has no place in pop music.

That's one of those rather hyperbolic statements that slightly inflates the degree of one's conviction in order to get the reader's attention while one explains themselves more rationally. So let me get to it.

It should be obvious to everyone interested that the canon of pop music forms a continuum throughout history- wherever you want to start that history- one could argue it started with musical theatre in New York, or that it started with the Scots-Irish settlers of the Appalachians, or that it started in the cotton fields of the American South, or that it started with the sea shanties of New Bedford and Marblehead, if they wanted to- it doesn't matter. The point is that pop music develops as various elements, sometimes similiar, sometimes dispirate, come together to make something new. It doesn't even have to be something really new, it could be, say, just taking the primal Motown stomp of say, "Sister Ray" and throwing Byrds-esqe twelve-string guitars and 4-part harmonies on top, and recording it all live in a tiny room with shitty Radio Shack mics. Sounds kinda neat, right? It could also be something that sounds shockingly original, just as, say, Captain Beefheart did in the late 60's- but if you want to be reductionist, there's a pretty good argument that all they did was take Chess Records blues ala Muddy Waters and Howling Wolf and throw in more dissonance and rythmic confusion- and sometimes just made the ugliest noises they could. But I'd argue that other people could have done it, too- maybe not sing like Don Van Vliet, but make something similiar to Beefheart by fucking around with something that came before until it was not too recognizable. It's not that complicated. The Rolling Stones only wound up sounding somewhat original because they tried to copy the blues and R&B of American (mostly black) artists and, through their own relative British honkey ineptitude, wound up creating something that was arguably even funkier than a lot of said American records. If you don't believe me, then listen to their first album, which is mostly covers- that's some of the funkiest, loosest blues-based music anybody ever recorded.

A lot of people will concede to the idea that pop music throughout history has evolved by synthesis, but you'll have a harder time convincing people that lifting bits of melody or a bassline or a drum beat or the like is a necessary part of pop music. Again, they're wrong. The Beatles did it constantly, right up until the end, and admitted to it openly and without guile. The Velvet Underground rip off Booker T. and the M.G.s for many of their songs, while "There She Goes Again" from the banana album opens with the exact same riff that opens Otis Redding's "Hitchhike", a cut that predated the VU song by at least two years (I'm guessing here). If you want me to, I'll stack a pile of "classic" pop albums and categorically point out where each part of each song came from. This is a language, people. It's got a vocabulary. If you think you're doing it in a vaccuum, you don't know much about music. And I'm guessing your music is not going to be very compelling. Pop music has a conversation with the listener- ideally, that conversation involves the pop song telling the listener about its little 3 minute universe. That's a real thing, as far as I'm concerned. Listen sometime to the song "Heart & Soul" by the Cleftones. That thing is coming right from outer space. All the same, it speaks the same language that all great pop does.

Punk rock is partially to blame for the modern conception that pop music as a purely expressive medium, where artists deliver their product directly to the audience, right from their heart, without the middle-man interference of the human intellect. Of course here I'm talking more about indie rock, really, because indie rock's got nothing to offer if not a superiority complex. Anyway, the point is, self-conciousness exists in most artists in great abundance- hyper creative people are very often the most self-concious people in the world. But hey, people really believed that Bob Dylan was an Okie who rode the rails to New York with nuthin' but a geetar on his back at one point, so why not make Iggy Pop into a savage, natural beast-man, churning out punk rock purity without even trying. It sells.

Addendum: One of my more popular (using THAT term loosely) songs came about as a result of falling in love with the song "Pink Frost" by The Chills. I thought The Chills' tune was great, but a little overlong, and lacking focus and some structure, so I decided I'd do a song with a similiar feel that was more concise and less self-indulgent in terms of structure. It was a successful experiment, I'd say, and it IS very similiar in many ways to "Pink Frost"- and that WAS by design. Now, a lot of people have never heard The Chills song, but of those who have, and have heard my song, a handful have pointed out that I ripped off the Chills song. This is true, I did, and I didn't try to hide it- yet they assert their discovery as if they've found me out, as if it's incredibly perceptive and clever. It's not. It's, at best, a banal observation, and certainly, in my mind, not a valid criticism. But "ripoff" is NEVER, in my mind, a valid criticism when it comes to pop songs. "This song sucks" would be perfectly acceptable, actually, but "hey, this is really similiar to this somewhat obscure song I know- you're busted, Mister" is not. Actually, rescuing whole songs or bits of songs from mediocrity or plain badness and reconfiguring them into something better is a GREAT songwriting exercise which I highly recommend.

I'm done for right now. Next: sincerity, and the problem with Devandra Newsom.