Monday, October 30, 2006

Making Up Songs

When I was a kid I used to make up songs all the time. This is common behavior for children but some of us get a little more into it than others. I remember a nonsensical (sarcastic !!!s) song called "Mommy Gaurami" that I used to sing while waiting to be picked up from school at the end of the day (this school didn't have a bus system- later in public high school, the bus ride home proved to be one of the best times to make up songs). Anyway, the song was based on "Is You Is Or Is You Ain't My Baby", at least the chords and the horn arrangement that ran through my head- although my melody was a little more....arabic? Anyway, I thought of this song years later as an adult and it occured to me that that horn line from it that I thought was so good was actually just ripped-off from "Is You Is?". But that was cool. I was a kid and I was using my imagination. That's never a bad thing.

A lot of songs, probably a lot of the best ones I'll ever make up, have been lost by virtue of not recording them in some fashion when they came into my head. When I was a drivin' man, it was kind of impossible- I'd have to wait till I got home to the four-track if something occurred to me, which meant I'd have to do nothing but sing the song until I was safely in front of a four track. An outside bit of music could easily derail the whole thing. Yet I let some songs go. I still have the vaguest memory of song I had in my head while driving down Pleasant St. in Amherst, MA., age 23. I wish I could actually remember it, but it's more like one of those abstract visuals that songs can become in my head- I can't remember anything about it other than its abstract visual is somewhat similiar to "Stephanie Says". It drives me nuts to this day as I'm quite sure it was great.

Nowadays, when something occurs to me, I call my cell phone and leave myself a message in which I hum the vocal melody, and bass riffs or drum things that are present, and mention the chord structure and approximate tempo. This is one of the only good things about cell phones for me. I thought of one song for the new album at 2:00 in the morning one winter night while walking from the subway- there's no way that one wouldn't have been swallowed by sleep. Luckiy I recorded a sketch of it.

Anyway, the thing I'm getting to is how different people conceptualize music. It does seem to be different from person to person. Personally, I think of music in three ways- one way is aural- that is usually regarding notes themselves. The second is color-coded- individual notes tend to imply colors. For example, C & E seem to be to be a blue and a darker blue. F is orange. A is red. The others are hazier but I won't go on.

The third way is the abstract visual way I mentioned before. This is even more pretentious-sounding than the color thing, so bear with me. Basically, a song or other piece of music will be represented by a visual in my head. Very often, especially for short-ish pop songs, this visual looks something like those line-perspective drawings you'd find in a book called "how to draw" or something. There's usually a front piece- somewhat like a giant, 3-dimensional letter in the alphabet, and there are lines coming from it going into a horizon. I don't think I could draw it. But it's there.

An orchestral, longer piece of music often looks like a dark, large pool of water. Sometimes it appears like a line drawing. Fast-paced bop or eary-60s modern jazz is weirdly more two-dimensional than either of them. I theorize that this is because the focus on a small number of instruments performing- i.e., lacking either the large variety of instruments of an orchestra or the production aspects of pop music, creates a much more simplistic image, despite the fact that the musical "sophistication" contained in such music tends to dwarf that of most pop or classic music- at least jazz of that period.

Anyway, I don't want to go on about jazz- but I will say this- I've heard from jazz snobs in the past (you only meet these people, generally, if you are or have been or hang out with jazz musicians, thank God) that their complaint with pop music is its lack of sophistication. I have to disagree. In terms of music theory, of course, this is correct. Most pop music is strictly diatonic or sparsely modal- the harmonic content does not stray far from the home key, in other words. It also tends to be short. Nonetheless, something that pop music, especially GREAT pop music, has in spades over classical or jazz is PRODUCTION. More than that, performances are informed by aesthetic concerns very often non existent in jazz and unheard of in classical.

That's why, for me, pop represents the pinnacle of achievement in Western music. There are no major aspects of jazz and classical that pop does not contain itself- the music is both partially pre-composed AND partially improvised. But jazz and classical lack the dimension of mechanical/analog/digital manipulation. They also lack the pretense of rock posturing- key to many of pop's greatest performances. For these reasons, pop offers more potential dimensions, more chances to be lost in an invented universe- more fantasy, to cut it short. Sound engineers who work in jazz do not often experiment in the studio. The focus is on respresenting the instruments realistically. Back when sound technology was in its relative infancy, this meant that jazz records sounded great. Now it means they sound sterile. Actually, this may lead to my talking about some recent production trends in pop and rock that make me unhappy. Maybe next time, though.

Wednesday, September 13, 2006

Stealing Is Good

About 6 years ago (ach!) I was in a band back in Massachusetts that was doing pretty well in our area. The band itself was a really loud pop band that sounded more like the Jesus & Mary Chain, David Bowie, and The Velvet Underground than anything else, with flourishes of Mission Of Burma and the like later. Anyway, your typical arty pop collage. At some point (I think after we opened up for -tah-dah!- Superdrag (whose "Sucked Out" marks, for me, one of the better moments in 90s mainstream radio) we got a blurb and a picture in the regional Village Voice- style liberal arts & news paper, and all hell broke loose in the letters section!!!

The guy who wrote the article was a really nice guy named Kebrew who lives in New York now. He said, in a nutshell, that we were really good, although we ripped various other bands off- but that we were still really good despite that- I believe pulling out the old "great artists steal" bit. Anyway, I recall being mildy annoyed that he felt compelled to mention it (even though it was true), but we were happy with the praise otherwise. The next week, there was an angry letter from a "local singer-songwriter"- (i.e., some po-mo folkie hack who does white melisma over sus4 and sus2 chords and calls it music) shaming said writer for praising a band who rips other songwriters off. They a whole diatribe about the importance of originality in music and your personal voice and a lot of other misguided hooey that could only come from someone who considers themselves an artist instead of a craftsman.

That's all fine for them, but let me say something- originality, just like sincerity, has no place in pop music.

That's one of those rather hyperbolic statements that slightly inflates the degree of one's conviction in order to get the reader's attention while one explains themselves more rationally. So let me get to it.

It should be obvious to everyone interested that the canon of pop music forms a continuum throughout history- wherever you want to start that history- one could argue it started with musical theatre in New York, or that it started with the Scots-Irish settlers of the Appalachians, or that it started in the cotton fields of the American South, or that it started with the sea shanties of New Bedford and Marblehead, if they wanted to- it doesn't matter. The point is that pop music develops as various elements, sometimes similiar, sometimes dispirate, come together to make something new. It doesn't even have to be something really new, it could be, say, just taking the primal Motown stomp of say, "Sister Ray" and throwing Byrds-esqe twelve-string guitars and 4-part harmonies on top, and recording it all live in a tiny room with shitty Radio Shack mics. Sounds kinda neat, right? It could also be something that sounds shockingly original, just as, say, Captain Beefheart did in the late 60's- but if you want to be reductionist, there's a pretty good argument that all they did was take Chess Records blues ala Muddy Waters and Howling Wolf and throw in more dissonance and rythmic confusion- and sometimes just made the ugliest noises they could. But I'd argue that other people could have done it, too- maybe not sing like Don Van Vliet, but make something similiar to Beefheart by fucking around with something that came before until it was not too recognizable. It's not that complicated. The Rolling Stones only wound up sounding somewhat original because they tried to copy the blues and R&B of American (mostly black) artists and, through their own relative British honkey ineptitude, wound up creating something that was arguably even funkier than a lot of said American records. If you don't believe me, then listen to their first album, which is mostly covers- that's some of the funkiest, loosest blues-based music anybody ever recorded.

A lot of people will concede to the idea that pop music throughout history has evolved by synthesis, but you'll have a harder time convincing people that lifting bits of melody or a bassline or a drum beat or the like is a necessary part of pop music. Again, they're wrong. The Beatles did it constantly, right up until the end, and admitted to it openly and without guile. The Velvet Underground rip off Booker T. and the M.G.s for many of their songs, while "There She Goes Again" from the banana album opens with the exact same riff that opens Otis Redding's "Hitchhike", a cut that predated the VU song by at least two years (I'm guessing here). If you want me to, I'll stack a pile of "classic" pop albums and categorically point out where each part of each song came from. This is a language, people. It's got a vocabulary. If you think you're doing it in a vaccuum, you don't know much about music. And I'm guessing your music is not going to be very compelling. Pop music has a conversation with the listener- ideally, that conversation involves the pop song telling the listener about its little 3 minute universe. That's a real thing, as far as I'm concerned. Listen sometime to the song "Heart & Soul" by the Cleftones. That thing is coming right from outer space. All the same, it speaks the same language that all great pop does.

Punk rock is partially to blame for the modern conception that pop music as a purely expressive medium, where artists deliver their product directly to the audience, right from their heart, without the middle-man interference of the human intellect. Of course here I'm talking more about indie rock, really, because indie rock's got nothing to offer if not a superiority complex. Anyway, the point is, self-conciousness exists in most artists in great abundance- hyper creative people are very often the most self-concious people in the world. But hey, people really believed that Bob Dylan was an Okie who rode the rails to New York with nuthin' but a geetar on his back at one point, so why not make Iggy Pop into a savage, natural beast-man, churning out punk rock purity without even trying. It sells.

Addendum: One of my more popular (using THAT term loosely) songs came about as a result of falling in love with the song "Pink Frost" by The Chills. I thought The Chills' tune was great, but a little overlong, and lacking focus and some structure, so I decided I'd do a song with a similiar feel that was more concise and less self-indulgent in terms of structure. It was a successful experiment, I'd say, and it IS very similiar in many ways to "Pink Frost"- and that WAS by design. Now, a lot of people have never heard The Chills song, but of those who have, and have heard my song, a handful have pointed out that I ripped off the Chills song. This is true, I did, and I didn't try to hide it- yet they assert their discovery as if they've found me out, as if it's incredibly perceptive and clever. It's not. It's, at best, a banal observation, and certainly, in my mind, not a valid criticism. But "ripoff" is NEVER, in my mind, a valid criticism when it comes to pop songs. "This song sucks" would be perfectly acceptable, actually, but "hey, this is really similiar to this somewhat obscure song I know- you're busted, Mister" is not. Actually, rescuing whole songs or bits of songs from mediocrity or plain badness and reconfiguring them into something better is a GREAT songwriting exercise which I highly recommend.

I'm done for right now. Next: sincerity, and the problem with Devandra Newsom.

Thursday, September 07, 2006

Butthead Pond

The Bevis Frond!

This is an interesting song called "Lights Are Changing" by

The Bevis Frond!


It popped up on Pandora right after some Modest Mouse song I could have done without (but which caused no great offense, either, which is sort of an offense in and of itself).

Anyway, the only way I could describe is that it kind of reminds me of a combination of The Byrds (quite easy to say as the backing is all jangly electric 12 string), Guided By Voices (cheap, relatively uncompressed recording, and a guitar solo that simply has to be a Danalectro plugged right into the board), and...I dunno, maybe the kind of song they'd play at the end of an episode of Buffy The Vampire slayer. There's something simultaneously pedestrian- proletariat, if we're being complimentary- and transcendent about the tune. I don't mean to be vague when I say transcedent, I just mean that there's an out-of-the-ordinary aspect to it that somehow makes it a better record than it should be.

Let's take a look at it, shall we?



I promise to start ftp'ing mp3s to this blog soon so you can interact more with what I'm talking about.

Anyway, it's nice- standard stuff, chord-wise- descending 1-7-6-5-4 roots in the chorus, subtle harmonies, nicely vague, vaguely triumphant lyrics- but there's DEFINITELY something about it that makes it rise above being a kind of collegey Roger McGuinn bit of dreck. I think it's mostly in the vocals and the production- the vocals, specifically, have a nice raggedness to them, and the timbre of his voice is warm and English but a little wierd. That combined with the lo-finess of the recording makes it work when it could easily be a snooze-fest. Yet another example of an inexpensive recording making a so-so song good.

Good songwriters would do well to remember that a pristine recording will never ADD anything to your music. All it will really do is expose its weaknesses.

Wednesday, September 06, 2006

Hello and welcome to the first posting of a songwriting blog. Songwriting is probably a little too specific- what I want to do with this blog is to talk about some of my feelings and theories as to what makes a great pop record. Perhaps I'll branch of into other idioms now and then, but pop itself, by my definition, is pretty broad, meaning anything that's NOT jazz or classical or world music. Within that framework, I'll consider Leadybelly and Mississipi John Hurt pop music just as I would The Ronnettes, or, say, Ace Of Base.

Normally when someone does this sort of thing it's because they've proven successful in the field they're getting pedantic about. That doesn't exactly describe me, uh, so much or anything, but I'm doing this anyway. Why? Because about 80% of my daily thoughts, waking and dreaming, are spent on the subject. Because it amuses me to think about and talk about and I'm assuming it will amuse me to write about as well. Because there's no other really good reason to do a craft other than the fact that it amuses you, and makes you at least useful to yourself. I'd argue that there's no other purpose in life, actually.

hi ho.

I am of the firm opinion that songwriting and record-making are crafts first and foremost, much as one would call carpentry, masonry, baking, cooking, or cabinet-making. My father was a cabinet-maker- I'd also call him an artist- but he certainly wasn't an artist on purpose. He didn't sit around thinking "I am an artist- I will await messages from the mystical doohickey yonder who will tell me how many dovetails to add to this chest-of-drawers". He went to the shop in the big red barn next to our house and he did his craft every day. To him, it was a skill-one to be improved through hard work, careful thought, practice, and persistence. There was nothing mystical about it. Yet he was an artist at it, and his pieces- often restorations or imitations of 17th & 18th century Shaker & Victorian furniture, had all the tell-tale signs of genius in them- and that's how people in his business regarded him.

Anyway, the point is, talent isn't something the person engaged in their craft should think about at all. Talent is something people accuse other people of having- but the reality is that good artists in any medium, more often than not, are skilled technicians of one sort or another, constantly pounding away at their figurative slab of marble, trying to get it perfect. That, to me, is what art is, but I prefer to call it craft, because people have so many unbelievably vain and silly ideas about ART.

So, then, I'm doing this mostly for my own amusement, and partially because I think that maybe talking about this stuff "out loud" will actually help me to improve my own craft. I'm also hoping to start a lot of conversations with whoever reads this thing. Little fascinates me more than how other people approach the same craft. So even if you're not a musician but have many strong ideas about what makes a pop song good, please do comment. I need brains.